The Case for Doing Less
Decades of research show that actively managed funds โ where a portfolio manager picks stocks โ underperform simple index funds over long periods. A 2023 S&P SPIVA report found that over 15 years, more than 88% of US large-cap fund managers underperformed the S&P 500 index.
You don't need a stock picker. You need a low-cost index fund and the discipline to leave it alone.
What Is Passive Investing?
Passive investing means owning a broad index โ typically the total US stock market, or the S&P 500 โ through a low-cost fund, and holding it for years without trading. The goal is to capture the market's return, not to beat it.
The three key principles:
- Diversification โ own thousands of stocks, not a handful
- Low costs โ expense ratios of 0.03โ0.05% vs. 0.5โ1%+ for actively managed funds
- Patience โ don't sell when markets drop; time in the market beats timing the market
Robo-Advisors: Passive Investing on Autopilot
A robo-advisor is an automated investment platform that builds and manages a diversified portfolio based on your risk tolerance and timeline. It handles allocation, rebalancing, and (in premium tiers) tax-loss harvesting โ all without you needing to make ongoing decisions.
The main platforms:
- Betterment โ strong tax-loss harvesting, goal-based accounts, $0 minimum
- Wealthfront โ Path financial planning tool, direct indexing at $100K+, $500 minimum
- Schwab Intelligent Portfolios โ no advisory fee (uses Schwab's own funds), $5,000 minimum
Robo-advisor fees of 0.25%/year are higher than DIY index fund investing but lower than human advisors (1%+), and the automation value is real for investors who lack the discipline to rebalance manually.
The DIY Alternative: Three-Fund Portfolio
The simplest passive investing strategy that doesn't require a robo-advisor:
- US total market index fund โ VTI, FZROX, or SWTSX (0โ0.03% expense ratio)
- International total market index fund โ VXUS or FZILX (0.07โ0.08% expense ratio)
- Bond index fund โ BND or FXNAX (0.03โ0.05% expense ratio)
Allocate based on your timeline: further from retirement = more stocks, less bonds. Rebalance once a year to your target allocation. That's it.
What Passive Investing Is Not
- It is not guaranteed returns โ markets decline, sometimes significantly
- It is not zero risk โ a total market fund will lose 30โ50% in a major bear market
- It does not require you to stop contributing โ automated monthly contributions into index funds is the ideal implementation
Ready to take action?
โจ Find the right product, faster
Credit cards, savings, loans, insurance, and investments โ compared side by side. Free, forever.
Get StartedCredit cards
Rewards, cash back & balance transfer
Savings accounts
Top APY rates compared
Personal loans
Best rates for every credit score
Insurance
Auto, home, life & more
Investing
Brokers, robo-advisors & ETFs
Auto loans
New, used & refinance
Credit cards
Rewards, cash back & balance transfer
Savings accounts
Top APY rates compared
Personal loans
Best rates for every credit score
Insurance
Auto, home, life & more
Investing
Brokers, robo-advisors & ETFs
Auto loans
New, used & refinance
Related guides
Best Investing Accounts for Retirement (2026)
IRAs, 401(k)s, and Roth accounts โ how to maximize tax-advantaged retirement savings
Best Platforms for Dividend Investing (2026)
DRIP programs, dividend yield, and the brokers that make income investing easiest
Best ESG Investing Platforms (2026)
Socially responsible investing โ how to align your portfolio with your values