What Is ESG Investing?
ESG stands for Environmental, Social, and Governance โ three criteria used to evaluate companies beyond pure financial performance:
- Environmental: Carbon footprint, energy efficiency, waste management, climate risk
- Social: Labor practices, supply chain ethics, data privacy, community impact
- Governance: Board diversity, executive compensation, shareholder rights, anti-corruption policies
ESG investing (also called socially responsible investing or sustainable investing) incorporates these factors into portfolio construction โ either by excluding companies that score poorly, overweighting companies that score well, or both.
ESG vs. Impact Investing vs. SRI
These terms are related but distinct:
SRI (Socially Responsible Investing) โ the original approach, typically using exclusion screens to remove "sin stocks" (tobacco, weapons, gambling, alcohol). Binary: in or out.
ESG Investing โ uses ESG scores as one input among many in portfolio construction. A company with low ESG scores isn't necessarily excluded โ it may be underweighted. More nuanced than pure exclusion.
Impact Investing โ directly targeting measurable social or environmental outcomes. Often involves private markets, green bonds, or direct investments in specific initiatives.
Does ESG Investing Underperform?
The evidence is mixed, and the debate is genuinely unsettled. Some findings:
- Several ESG funds outperformed standard indexes during the 2020โ2021 period
- ESG funds typically have higher expense ratios than comparable passive index funds
- ESG screening often results in less diversification (fewer holdings)
- Performance varies significantly by the specific ESG methodology used
The honest answer: if your goal is maximizing expected return while minimizing risk, a low-cost total market index fund is hard to beat. If your goal includes aligning your investments with your values โ even at a small cost โ ESG products serve a real purpose.
What to Look for in an ESG Platform
Transparent ESG methodology. Who rates the companies, and how? MSCI, Sustainalytics, and FTSE Russell are major ESG data providers with different methodologies. A fund labeled "ESG" from one provider might include companies you'd consider non-ESG by another standard.
Low expense ratios. ESG funds have historically charged higher fees than conventional index funds, though this gap has narrowed. Look for ESG ETFs under 0.20% expense ratio.
Broad diversification. An ESG fund with 50 holdings is less diversified than the S&P 500's 500 holdings. Risk-adjusted performance suffers when concentration increases.
Thematic options. If you have specific values โ clean energy, gender equity, no weapons โ look for funds with transparent thematic screens rather than broad ESG ratings that may not align with your specific concerns.
Ready to take action?
โจ Find the right product, faster
Credit cards, savings, loans, insurance, and investments โ compared side by side. Free, forever.
Get StartedCredit cards
Rewards, cash back & balance transfer
Savings accounts
Top APY rates compared
Personal loans
Best rates for every credit score
Insurance
Auto, home, life & more
Investing
Brokers, robo-advisors & ETFs
Auto loans
New, used & refinance
Credit cards
Rewards, cash back & balance transfer
Savings accounts
Top APY rates compared
Personal loans
Best rates for every credit score
Insurance
Auto, home, life & more
Investing
Brokers, robo-advisors & ETFs
Auto loans
New, used & refinance
Related guides
Best Investing Accounts for Retirement (2026)
IRAs, 401(k)s, and Roth accounts โ how to maximize tax-advantaged retirement savings
Best Platforms for Dividend Investing (2026)
DRIP programs, dividend yield, and the brokers that make income investing easiest
Best Platforms for Passive Investing (2026)
Index funds, robo-advisors, and automation โ how to invest without actively managing anything