Third Federal Savings & Loan HELOC vs. Earnest Student Loan Refinance

Side-by-side comparison ยท Updated 2026 ยท Independently reviewed

Third Federal Savings & Loan logo
Third Federal Savings & Loan HELOC
Third Federal Savings & Loan
4.6

Perennial rate leader for traditional HELOCs. Low variable rates, no origination fee, $65/yr annual fee.

Full review โ†’
Earnest logo
Earnest Student Loan Refinance
Earnest
4.5

APR 4.96โ€“9.99%. Precision pricing. No fees.

Full review โ†’
WealthSpott Verdict

Earnest Student Loan Refinance wins on more measurable categories โ€” particularly on rate and cost. Third Federal Savings & Loan HELOC may still be the right fit depending on your loan amount and term needs.

Feature
Third Federal Savings
Earnest Student Loan
APR Range
6.49% โ€“ 7.99%
4.96% โ€“ 9.99% Best
Loan Amount
$10,000 โ€“ $200,000
$5,000 โ€“ $500,000 Best
Term Length
120โ€“360 months
60โ€“240 months
Origination Fee
No origination fee; $65/year annual fee
None
Min Credit Score
660+
650+ Best
Funding Speed
2โ€“4 weeks
2โ€“3 weeks
Third Federal Savings & Loan HELOC
Full review
Earnest Student Loan Refinance
Full review

Not sure which loan is right for you?

Browse all loans