Amica Mutual Homeowners Insurance vs. Guardian Disability Insurance

Side-by-side comparison · Updated 2026 · Independently reviewed

Amica Mutual Homeowners Insurance

Amica Mutual

4.6

J.D. Power 906/1000. Annual dividends reduce premiums 5–20%. Best claims handling.

Full review →

Guardian Disability Insurance

Guardian Life

4.5

All 50 states. A++ rated. Group + individual policies. Long-term specialist.

Full review →

WealthSpott Verdict

Amica Mutual Homeowners Insurance wins on more measurable categories. Guardian Disability Insurance may still be worth a quote depending on your location and coverage needs — premiums vary widely.

Feature

Amica Mutual Homeowners

Guardian Disability Insurance

WealthSpott Rating

4.6 / 5 Best

4.5 / 5

Coverage Type

Home Insurance

Disability Insurance

Avg Annual Premium

~$2,000/yr Best

—

AM Best Rating

—

J.D. Power Score

—

Mobile App Rating

—

Amica Mutual Homeowners Insurance

Full review

Guardian Disability Insurance

Pros

Available in all 50 states
A++ AM Best financial strength
Group and individual policies available

Cons

Application process can be slow
Premiums above average for individual plans

Full review

Not sure which insurer is right for you?

Browse all insurance